fallacy.wiki

A field guide to the ways reasoning breaks

Crowds and prestige

Appeal to common practice

Also called Everyone does it

What it is

Justifying an action because it is widely done, rather than because it is right.

In the wild

Everybody rounds up their hours on timesheets, so it is fine.

How to answer it

Separate frequency from justification. Ask whether the practice would survive being stated openly.

In depth

Origin and naming

The everyday version of ad populum aimed at conduct rather than belief: 'everyone does it' offered as a permit. Textbooks have listed it for decades, usually as a cousin of the bandwagon and of 'two wrongs make a right'.

More places it shows up

  1. Every shop on this street leaves the excess packaging loose on the pavement, so our pile is nothing unusual.

  2. All the parents let their kids keep phones at the dinner table; being strict about it would only make you the outlier.

  3. Everyone in the league parks across two spaces on match day, so one more car makes no difference.

  4. Every freelancer I know inflates the estimate a bit to cover delays — it is simply how the work gets quoted.

How to spot it

  • Listen for the shift from 'is it right?' to 'how common is it?' — the second question quietly answers the first.
  • Notice when the defence would embarrass its user if read aloud at a meeting: secrecy is doing the moral work.
  • Notice when the defence collapses the moment one person in the room says they do not do it.

Read more