fallacy.wiki

A field guide to the ways reasoning breaks

Distraction and distortion

Red herring

Also called Ignoratio elenchi, irrelevant conclusion

What it is

Introducing a side issue that draws attention away from the question at hand.

In the wild

Why worry about the deadline when the office coffee is terrible?

How to answer it

Return to the original question out loud and park the new topic for later.

In depth

Origin and naming

A red herring is a heavily smoked fish with a strong smell. The idiom was popularized by the journalist William Cobbett in 1807, in a story about dragging a kipper across a trail to pull hounds off the scent — the fish that leads the dogs astray.

More places it shows up

  1. Asked about the hospital's infection rates, the health minister praises the dedication of the nursing staff at length.

  2. Questioned about a product's security flaw, the company's statement explains how many jobs it supports in the region.

  3. A roommate asked about the unpaid rent launches into how rarely anyone else does the dishes.

  4. A council member, pressed on a missing infrastructure budget, delivers a heartfelt speech about the town's proud history.

How to spot it

  • Notice when the reply is fluent, emotional and entirely compatible with every possible answer to the question.
  • Notice when you can't restate the original question from the response you just heard.
  • Notice when the new topic is easier to defend than the one raised — that's why it was raised.

Read more